Cultured dairy foods enjoy a long and vibrant history. In every society that historically consumed dairy foods, cultured yogurt and other probiotic dairy foods earned a much-loved and much-respected place in the indigenous diets. That place was rightly deserved, too. While culturing milk and cream inevitably offered the practical benefit of enabling dairy foods to last longer; it also enhanced their nutrient profile. Cultured dairy products like raw milk yogurt and milk kefir offer the same probiotic benefits that you’ll find in true sour pickles or real sauerkraut coupled with the beneficial nutrients found in animal foods like preformed vitamin A (did you know about the connection between maternal vitamin A intake and cleft palate?), beta carotene, vitamin K2 and CLA- particularly if the animals were pasture- or grass-fed.There’s life beyond yogurt and kefir, though. Cultured dairy foods are as diverse as the societies that cherished them. Here’s a look at ten cultured dairy foods – some might be new to you! Here’s a little thing I love about cultured milk products: they all seem to offer double vowels – blaand, piimä, chaas, viili.
1. Bonny Clabber
Bonny clabber is a traditional cultured dairy food in both the Southern United States and in Scotland. In the United States, it was customarily eaten with molasses, cinnamon and nutmeg for breakfast. Bonny clabber is a wild-cultured dairy food in that it requires no starter; rather, its probiotic properties stem directly from the natural flora in the milk and in your home. In that respect, it’s similar to a wild sourdough. Preparing bonny clabber is simple: take raw whole milk (and, yes, it absolutely must be raw) and leave it on your counter until the milk solids naturally separate from the whey – developing a thick and yogurt-like consistency. You’ve made bonny clabber as simple as that.
2. Filmjölk
Filmjölk is a Swedish cultured dairy food that is mildly sour in flavor and remarkably versatile. Filmjölk, like most of the tastiest cultured dairy foods, is cultured at room temperature without the need for a heat source or yogurt maker. This makes it particularly easy to work with. Filmjölk earns its tangy taste from lactococcus lactis and leuconostoc mesenteroides. These bacteria, like other involved in fermentation, render the milk slightly acid and that acidic environment coagulates the milk’s natural proteins turning the milk into sour, thick Filmjölk. To prepare Filmjölk, you’ll need to obtain a starter culture from a reliable source. I serve my Filmjölk over fruit in the morning or, from time to time, make homemade Filmjök Ranch Dressing. You can purchase starters online (see sources).
3. Viili
Viili is also a cultured dairy food of Scandinavian origin. Viili originally hails from Sweden but is now found in Finland where it is largely considered a national treasure. Viili’s ropy, unctuous and gelatinous texture is produced by a combination of yeast and lactic acid bacteria. I’ve read that a good viili can reach lenghty ropes of up to 1 foot or longer without breaking, but I’ve yet to see it. The flavor of viili is mildly sour in comparison to other cultured dairy products which makes it a good option for children or folks who are just wetting their feet in the territory of naturally sour probiotic foods. Viili is traditionally served with a touch of sweetener or gooseberry jam and is quite good served as a parfait with layers of all-fruit jam sandwiched between the viili. Viili is cultured at room temperature so you do not need a yogurt maker, only a starter culture which you can purchase online (see sources).
4. Piimä
Piimä, like many of the other cultured dairy foods described here, is of Scandinavian origin. It has a sour flavor coupled with the subtle nuances of a mild cheese. This combination of flavors makes piimä particularly well suited to savory dishes (check out my pan-fried brussels sprouts with piima cream) and it is, according to my little boy, the best and most delicious of the cultured milk products. Unlike other cultured dairy foods, piimä is thin in consistency and is traditionally used as a beverage similarly to buttermilk. Piimä is easy to prepare because it, like many cultured dairy foods, it is mesophillic meaning that it cultures at room temperature instead of through added heat. All you need is a starter culture with which you can innoculate your milk with the strains of beneficial microbiota that make piimä particularly unique. Piimä can be cultured indefinitely, with proper care, and you can find your initial starter online (see sources).
5. Matsoni
Matsoni is an Eastern European cultured dairy food with a heritage attributed to Bulgaria, Georgia, Armenia or Russia depending on who you talk to. Lore promises that matsoni will prolong life and there may be something to that as we’re just now beginning to understand the mechanisms surrounding how fermented and cultured foods benefit our long-term health. Matsoni is produced through unique strains of lactic acid bacteria which produce this mildly sour yogurt with a syrupy consistency. Children are particularly fond of it. Matsoni is particularly good for breakfast, but I also like it poured over fruit for dessert. Matsoni is also mesophillic so it requires very minimal effort to prepare. Just mix a starter culture with fresh milk and leave it on your counter to culture for a day or two depending on the temperature of your home. See sources for a starter culture, and this is my preferred yogurt for making labneh, or yogurt cheese.
6. Buttermilk (Cultured)
When I think of buttermilk, I invariably think of the scene in Some Like it Hot when Spats announces he’s drinking buttermilk to a visibly disappointed police chief. I don’t know why, it’s just always there lurking in the recesses of my childhood memories when we’d spend entire summers watching old black and white movies. Buttermilk is traditionally made from the thin milk reserved from making cultured butter; however, many traditional food lovers are now using a starter culture and making whole-milk buttermilk. Buttermilk’s sour flavor is the result of lactic acid bacteria – particularly streptococcus lactis or lactobacillus bulgaricus. It can be enjoyed in a variety of ways, but it is particularly well suited to baking – granted, that destroys the beneficial bacteria – but it makes a killer bread or cake (check out my soaked flour gingerbread). Or, like Spats, you can drink it plain as was popular until the middle of the 20th century. Take care not ot purchase or use most store-bought buttermilks as even the organic versions often contain fillers instead of pure, cultured milk. Instead, make your own using a starter culture (see sources).
7. Chaas (Traditional Buttermilk)
Traditionally buttermilk was not cultured as buttermilk in and of itself; rather, it was simply the thin liquid leftover from making butter. This traditional buttermilk is versatile and rich in the natural beneficial bacteria found in the raw milk itself. Alternatively, it may be rich in the bacteria that was introduced into the whole milk prior to culturing it for buttermaking as in the case of cultured butter. Now, aside from a few home kitchens, traditional buttermilk is only really used in India where it is called chaas. In India, chaas is often flavored with salt, cumin, chilies and other spices much in the same way that bonny clabber is flavored with nutmeg and molasses in the west. You can prepare chaas by first making butter (learn how to make butter) then straining the resultant liquid. Now you have chaas or traditional buttermilk, no starter culture is typically needed.
8. Blaand
Blaand is a traditional Scottish drink made from fermented whey with quite an alcoholic kick. While it’s been made for centuries in Scotland, it has largely fallen out of favor perhaps, in part, to the decline of home cheesemaking and the increased availability of other alcoholic beverages. First, whey is reserved from cheesemaking or, I imagine, you could use the whey leftover from Bonny Clabber or strained yogurt as well. But, if you’re adventerous enough to attempt to make blaand, you’re probably adventerous enough to make cheese too. That whey is then traditionally poured into an oak cask similarly to wine, and allowed to sit until the desired flavor and alcohol content are acheived. When the fermentation is complete, blaand should have an alcohol content similar to wine. Take care, because if you allow it to ferment too long you’ll end up with whey vinegar instead of blaand, and that’s decidedly unpleasant.
9. Kefir
Kefir (pictured above) is a cultured milk product that, unlike the others mentioned here, results from the introduction of kefir grains into raw milk instead of through wild, spontaneous fermentation as in the case of bonny clabber or via starter culture as in the case of viili. Kefir grains are small, spongy, symbiotic colonies of beneficial yeast and bacteria with an appearance that resembles cottage cheese. Kefir is a strikingly tart cultured dairy beverage with a slight effervescence that takes some getting used to. Kefir originally comes from the Caucasus region where, legend has it, the grains were guarded for their life-prolonging properties. That may, indeed, have some merit as kefir is rich in nutrients including folic acid and the kefiran in it has been linked the supression of high blood pressure. Traditionally, raw milk was mixed with kefir grains and placed in animal skin pouches to ferment. Don’t have an animal skin pouch or don’t want to use one? You can culture kefir in a glass container like a mason jar by mixing the kefir grains with fresh raw milk and allowing it to culture 1 day or longer (a longer ferment produces more nutrients, but renders a sourer beverage). Purchase a kefir grains (see sources), and learn how to brew milk kefir with this simple tutorial.
10. Yogurt
What would a post about cultured dairy products be without a mention of yogurt? When used broadly, yogurt can describe any of the fermented dairy foods listed above with the exception of blaand, kefir and possibly chaas; however, yogurt is unique in and of itself. Yogurt is the only fermented dairy food on this list that is thermophillic – meaning that it requires a heat source in order to culture properly. In that respect, yogurt is relatively unique. Yogurt is made by culturing milk with a variety of lactic acid producing, thermophillic bacteria. The most common and well known strain of bacteria in yogurt is lactobacillus bulgaricus, though many other strains of bacteria are used as well. To make yogurt, you’ll need a constant, but mild heat source and a starter culture. If you plan to make yogurt regularly, I recommend purchasing a yogurt maker – they’re reasonably affordable and make culturing yogurt fool-proof such as this one which produces 2-quarts or this one which produces individual servings. You’ll also need to acquire a starter culture – you can purchase powdered yogurt starter for Greek or Bulgarian yogurt (see sources) or, more simply, use a few tablespoons of store-bought plain yogurt to start your batch. If you use a store-bought yogurt, make sure it has several varieties of live bacteria and contains no sugar, fillers or other strange things.
Maintaing a Pure Starter for Raw Milk Yogurts
Just one last note before you begin: if you’re planning to produce raw milk yogurts and cultured dairy products (with the exception of bonny clabber, chaas, blaand and kefir), it’s important to maintain a pure starter with which you can reculture the milk. If you fail to maintain a pure starter, the natural bacteria in your raw milk will eventually overtake the bacterial strains in the starter and you’ll no longer make viili, piimä etc.; rather, you’ll simply be making clabbered milk. To keep a pure starter, boil and cool milk to eliminate its natural bacteria and culture that milk with your starter on a weekly basis, then use a few tablespoons of the boiled milk starter in raw milk to culture raw milk yogurt.
Kefir Grains, originally uploaded by muckster.
EcoYogini says
How interesting! I had no idea these existed 🙂
It’s funny, as talking to my father who grew up with cows, they ate traditional buttermilk and raw milk growing up. it’s so sad that these practices have fallen away to the Big Farming industry.
Thank you for this info! 🙂
Check out EcoYogini’s last post: Cornicopia and Us..
Julie says
Great info! Cultured dairy is so important from a nutritional standpoint and in some cases, people who are not able to drink milk may be able to tolerate cultured dairy products.
Check out Julie’s last post: How to Make Cultured Butter.
sara says
this is so good
henriette says
Danish tykmælk( thick milk) basically a sour milk
What the farmers had all summer.
1 liter wholefat milk
heat and add
100 ml whipping cream.
let it cool to body temperature and add
100 ml real old fashioned buttermilk( the type that come from cultured butter making)
pour into 4- 5 bowls and place a plate over each bowl so no flies or dust can enter milk.
Let it stand in a hot kitchen 12-18 hours and transfer to the fridge and let it get very cold.
You´ll have a thick layer of cream and a bottom of mild tart fermented milk.
In Denmark we eat it with roasted crumbled ryebread and molasses sugar
or strawberries and honey.
Check out henriette’s last post: Asparges.
Jenny says
Henriette – that sounds delicious! I bet it’s over the top with strawberries and honey.
Sarah says
Great post! I’ve been meaning to make piima and creme fraiche at home, but now see there is a whole world of cultured dairy to try!
When my grandmother was a baby, her mother couldn’t nurse her after a few months . . . they tried lots of different milks but she couldn’t stomach any of them. Except buttermilk (the original kind, not cultured.) Now that we know more about the makeup of human milk (i.e. it’s lower fat content in comparison to cows, etc.) it makes sense to me! These days they’d probably pump her up with soy formula . . . yuck.
Thanks again for the post!
Best,
Sarah
Bryan - oz4caster says
Very interesting. I hadn’t heard of matsoni or blaand before. Cultured raw dairy is a healthy food if you don’t add any sweetener. It may be an acquired taste, especially if you haven’t managed to get rid of that sweet tooth yet 🙂
If you just have to make it sweeter, adding a little fresh fruit is the healthiest way. Most commercial cultured milk is loaded with sugar or artificial sweeteners and should be avoided.
I make my own kefir once or twice a week and always drink it plain.
Check out Bryan – oz4caster’s last post: Flu Factories.
Annie - Hip Organic Mama says
WOW – this is such an impressive post. Your knowledge and understanding of food is remarkable – I learn something every time I visit and I get inspired to try something new. Thank you!
Check out Annie – Hip Organic Mama’s last post: Why Choose Organic?.
Jenny says
You guys are so thoughtful! It really is amazing when it comes to cultured dairy foods. And there’s A LOT more than the ten I listed here – of course, most of them are a alternate form of bonny clabber. I might have to make some this weekend and do a tutorial.
Michelle @ Find Your Balance says
Jenny this is so cool. And I just noticed your starter exchange. Way to go woman! This is good stuff. My husband has made yogurt but we haven’t tried any of the others. Bonny Clabber? That sounds made up! 🙂
Check out Michelle @ Find Your Balance’s last post: Easter egg radishes, from tips to tops.
Tiffany says
I have a question . . . In NT, Fallon states that viili is similiar to piima milk and suitable for using to make baby formula (ie thin enough to pass through the nipple of a bottle). Is this true? I need to travel with my son and unable to nurse; I’m looking for a substitute for the raw milk with which I ususal make his formula and that viili would be a good alternative because the flavor is supposed to be less tart.
Thanks!
Jenny says
Tiffany – That’s one area of NT where I think Fallon is absolutely wrong. Viili and Piima aren’t really all that similar. Their flavors are different, and so is the texture. I really couldn’t see viili fitting through the the nipple of a bottle due to its viscous and ropy nature. You might try matsoni which is mildly tart and not as viscous as viili. Piima is thin, but cheesy in flavor. Is it at all possible for you to pump and bottlefeed expressed milk or find milk donated from a mother you trust? I’m not too familiar with NT-style infant formulas.
Alchemille says
Thank you for posting this.
I knew about some of them (I make my own filmjolk and matsoni…Used to make viili too) but never heard about a few others.
The Bonny Clabber sounds like fun to make & taste ;).
Check out Alchemille’s last post: Nourishing & Gluten Free Meal Planning.
Alchemille says
I have one question about the bonny clabber now that I am re-reading everything…Once the milk solids separate from the whey, you can collect the whey and keep it in the fridge for later use, right?
Check out Alchemille’s last post: Nourishing & Gluten Free Meal Planning.
Jenny says
Alchemille – Yes, exactly! Isn’t the simplicity of waste-not-want-not attitude of traditional foods so beautiful. Nothing is wasted.
Zeke says
It has always been my understanding that Chaas was yogurt and water, like a very thin salt lassi.
Check out Zeke’s last post: Eat your weed.
Jenn AKA The Leftover Queen says
Cultured dairy products are my favorite.I love them – love eating them, and love working with them. They are magical!
I always have kefir and viili going in my house, but want to add Filmjölk and Piimä to it, but am having trouble thinking how I will be able to manage to eat enough, so I can re-culture within the week. Any thoughts on that?
I really want to try Henriette’s tykmjelk too! Sounds like heaven!
Dana says
Jenny,
Thank you for the tip on keeping a pure starter. Years ago I used to culture my own raw milk yogurt from our farm-fresh goats milk. I never understood why it would eventually stop working. I know now why! I can’t wait to try it again!
Thank you so much…
Peace,
Dana
Alex at A Moderate Life says
HI Jen Jenny, this is a great article and I would love to share it on my thoughts on friday link love post because I think people need to see just how many options there are out there for cultured dairy. I have made bonny clabber and then made mozzarella out of it by accident! What fun it is to play with your food! My yogurt never did come out well, what type of pan do you cook your milk in? Mine always seems to curdle at around the temp needed to start culturing! Could it be my all clad pan? thanks for sharing this great information with us! 🙂 Alex@amoderatelife
Hannah says
Excellent post! I’m experimenting with old raw milk and kefir grains – it looks crazy! But I can handle the sour – think I’ll add some fruit & honey to taste.
Dani says
Re buttermilk.
What Ive done for a few years to make buttermilk. I originally bought your standard small buttermilk from the store and used that to inoculate a couple of quarts of raw milk, which turned into buttermilk. I then froze some of that buttermilk in an ice cube tray. Now when I want buttermilk I simply take out a cube if frozen buttermilk pop it into a quart of milk and wait 8-12 hours.
Once I left it on the counter for too long and it produced something similar to your description of Viili, with long strings of thick sour cream like tasting substance. My partner refused to try it, but I really liked it. I called it filmjolk at the time becasue I had no idea what I had created.
From what you said, all this can potentially corrupt the original strain of buttermilk. So I guess if you really want pure buttermilk then definitely buy buttermilk culture from a retailer. But so far Ive had fun playing with whatever fermented milk I can create using store bought items. I’m often surprised with something new. I also make Kifer which is often my buttermilk stand-in in recipes, works out great.
Michelle (Health Food Lover) says
Hi Jenny,
Thanks for the great list and info!
Two years ago I went to South Africa and I tried to taste as many ‘traditional’ foods as I could. One of the food I tried was Amasi which is basically soured milk.
Sarah says
About your tip for keeping a pure starter. Instead of heating milk at home would using just a regular pasteurized milk work fine to keep the starter pure? Though i want to branch out, kefir is the only culture I’m currently keeping, so this question would apply mainly to kefir grains, for me.
Chris @ Earth Friendly Goodies says
What a wonderfully tongue twisting over view of cultured milk – there are quite a few that I hadn’t heard about before. I’ve been wanting to try a milk or water kefir, but I’m not sure if I have the dedication to talking care of the grains. 🙂 I’ve been wondering though how do you pronounce Kefir? Is it pronounced more like keefer or keffir?
Jenny says
You should pronounce kefir like this: keh-FEAR. You should try a milk kefir. It’s lovely!
amy says
Is it only necessary to purify your raw milk starter for yogurt, or do you need to do that for kefir and the other cultured dairy as well?
Jenny says
Only for yogurt.
Charlene says
Thanks, I just discovered Kombucha and now I’m anxious to start trying other cultured and fermented foods, so this post couldn’t have come at a better time for me 🙂
nichole says
I am still a little confused about the starter with raw milk. I boil the milk & mix in the starter for
he mother culture, then every week boil more milk and add the mother to it to make more starter? Sorry to be so dumb. Just want to get it straight in my mind.
Thanks
Jenny says
That’s correct. You’ve got it. Then you use the yogurt made from boiled milk as your starter for raw milk yogurt.
Patricia says
Okay… this is my same question. I’m still a tad confused. You just make a small amount of boiled milk.. half a cup?, culture it then use that culture in the remaining say quart or gallon of raw milk?
Someone else asked if you could just use some store bought pasteurized milk for the same purpose.
Thanks for your patience.
kathie says
Thank you for your posts – always interesting. I just wanted to add that I keep a jar of clabber going all the time on my kitchen counter. It’s perfect for culturing cream for butter and also perfect for culturing milk for cottage cheese and farmers cheese. Each time I scoop some out to use, I simply replace that amount with fresh raw milk. If the kitchen is real hot in the summer, I put the clabber in the refrigerator, but most of the year, it just sits out, covered with cheesecloth. Also, a nice “sweet” clabber usually takes a couple of dilutions. So, let the milk set out for a few days til it is solid, then dump half out and freshen with new milk, clabber it again, dump half out and add fresh. After about 3 times, you get a nice pleasant smelling clabber to keep. The first one or two are usually too strong for use in making butter or cheese.
Ann says
What is cultured butter? Is it beneficial only when eaten raw? Is it, or can it be, salted and still cultured?
Jenny says
In cultured butter the a starter culture is added to the cream (pasteurized or raw) before it is churned into butter. It’s yummy. I don’t buy salted butter, so I’m not sure if you can find salted+cultured butter.
kathie says
I salt mine. Besides flavor, the number reason I only make cultured butter is shelf life. Sweet cream butter goes “off” flavor fast. My cultured butter stays good for days, left out.
Kinzi says
Can traditional buttermilk (the liquid leftover after making raw cultured butter from raw cream) be used as a starter in whole raw milk to make cultured whole milk buttermilk?
kathie says
I don’t see why not. Try it. I use my buttermilk (left from cultured butter) as a starter for cheese, so I don’t see why it wouldn’t turn whole milk.
Deana says
I already make raw-milk kefir at home and yogurt in the yogurt maker. I’m looking at the source page for the starters and all I see are yogurt starters. Is that what is used to make the matsoni and other yogurt-y things? If so, can I just use some of my kefir or some of my yogurt as a starter? And if so, how much? I’m intrigued by these milder things, as my kids won’t go NEAR the kefir.
Jenny says
No, unfortunately, you can’t use your established starter to make the other cultured dairy foods. They differ not on how they’re prepared which is pretty basic, but on the bacteria in the starter which differs from variety to variety. Personally, I only recommend culturing one yogurt (that you love) and kefir. Otherwise it gets to be too much to worry about and you have to worry about cross-contamination.
jess says
love this post. i wish my grandmother was still around to see the kefir on my counter top. she used to make ‘clabber’ when my mom was a kid. she hung hers outside on a clothesline, right after milking the cow. i love the idea of a wild-cultured dairy food. i only wish i had my own cow to milk!
Stephanie says
I have a question about keeping a pure yogurt starter. Are you using yogurt from the previous batch for the starter that you add to the boiled milk? If so, wouldn’t the natural bacteria in the milk still be contaminating the starter? I may be overthinking it…
Missy says
I am going to make bonny clabber with
raw goat milk. Should I cover it with a lid, or leave the lid off?
Julie says
Hi, Do you HAVE to boil milk each time to maintain a clean culture? Is that what people used to do? I want to maintain a raw product and not kill the good bacteria in the milk.