Brown soda bread offers nourishment, a rich flavor and is quite simple to prepare in any kitchen - emboldening the the repertoire of even the novice cook. While the Irish are known for their traditional soda bread which combines little else but flour, buttermilk, salt and baking soda, many home cooks have adjusted the recipe with the inclusion of raisins, currants and other ingredients. This brown soda bread with currants and caraway is no exception.
A tradition that may predate the popularization of soda bread in 1840s Ireland, the combination of an acid (buttermilk) and a base (baking soda) creates a reaction that causes the bread to rise without aid of baking yeast or sourdough starter. Some evidence indicates that combining an acid with a base to leaven bread may have also occured in the Americas with the traditional methods of baking employed by Native Americans who used potash in place of baking soda and another acidic medium in place of buttermilk. Regardless of the method's earliest origins, the Irish have, undoubtedly, made it their own. It is a fast, simple and humble bread that appealed to Ireland's poor and working class families.
In my version of soda bread, I prefer to soak the flour - a soft wheat - with buttermilk overnight or longer. This practices helps to mitigate the effects of phytic acid, an antinutrient naturally found in whole grain that binds minerals and preventing their full absorption by the body. Soaking flour in an acidic medium, such as buttermilk or soured milk, for several hours not only improves the not only the digestibility of the grain, but also the body's ability to absorb whole grain's natural, full array of micronutrients. Moreover, soaking flour helps to acidify the dough which produces a pleasantly tender crumb when baked.
Try these recipes next
Jessica Campbell says
Hi Jenny, I make this every year and everyone loves it! I would like to use some of my sourdough starter this year, do you think I should make any substitutions for the flour and buttermilk as far as liquid/dry ingredients?
Kathy says
Thanks for the amazing recipe. I've just made it without the whiskey and caraway seeds as I didn't have them. Tastes gorgeous! It's great for me as I'm trying to eat less yeast. And I made a gluten-free version at the same time - with sorghum flour (3 1/2 cups) and rice flour (2 cups) and a bit of xanthum gum. I soaked them overnight too. Tastes wonderful. Very different to the wheat one but equally as good.
Nicole says
i followed your recipe and for the amount of flour it was not enough buttermilk. The edges dried out and it was very difficult to mix...the flour was sprouted and dried than- i milled it at home...Not sure why this did not come out that great?
Should i put more of "wet agent" in there? Thank you for your suggestions...
Jenny says
It sounds like you didn't follow the recipe. I recommend following the recipe, using the flour listed above.
Michele Heath says
I hope this is not a terribly ridiculous question, but can I just leave out the carraway seeds and currants? I"m sure it would be wonderful, but can we leave them out and still make a good bread? Are there any adjustments if we leave it out?
Allison Garcia says
Oh no! I don't have caraway seeds, and I want to make this in the morning. Is there something I could switch it for, or should I just leave it out? I have fennel (not my favorite flavor). Let me know ASAP. Thanks!!!
Kristin Koblentz says
I'm going to give this recipe a try tonight! But I have just one question: what's the purpose of soaking the dough if the flour is already sprouted?
jenny says
There's a school of thought within traditional foods that says sprouting is not sufficient to reduce phytate; another school of thought says soaking in buttermilk is not sufficient to reduce phytate. With this recipe, you've got all your bases covered. Me? I just *really* like the flavor of sprouted flour.
Claudia says
Will it work just as well with kefir instead of buttermilk? That's what I usually have around since I culture it.
Chelsea Wipf says
This turned out so good! It really makes a massive loaf though...probably because the dough is so wet. I will be keeping this recipe as my go-to Irish Soda Bread!
jessie says
Hi,
I'm wondering if you have any techniques to make these soaked flour recipes a little less...dense! I usually make all of my recipes this way, and have found my finished product to occaisionally have just the right amount of crumb and seem more or less normal density. Since I don't use tons of grains or do loads of baking, I'm always trying to figure out what has made the difference here! I've experimented with more or fewer eggs, baking powder or not, etc...Any suggestions? I've also experienced the dreaded "Oh-crap-my-crust-is-burning-and-the-inside-is-still-wet", but less often. How is the texture and density of your soda bread? At least these breads tend to have superior flavor...
Thanks!
j
djseaweed says
hi, nice to see someone interested in making real food. you could have mentioned that it might not be a coincidence that in a country where the traditional wheat bread is neither fermented or soaked that the population has a very high rate of both celiac disease and schizophrenia. anyway, i have a question. if i make sprouted wheat bread i soak and sporout the wheat for maybe 3 days then grind it wet; it makes a moist, malty sweet loaf. from what you say, and the link to the sprouted flour people, their flour would make bread more like the 'ordinary bread' that we are used to. that is it must be soaked/germinated for a much shorter period of time, so it's not as sweet and malty. is this the case?
Evelina says
I'm at 500 ft. above sea level, so I lowered the higher temp to 400 (minus 25 degrees, per high altitude alterations) for the first 25 minutes, then lowered it to 350 for the remaining 20 minutes and the bread cooked just right. Unfortunately I misplaced my caraway this morning, so we are enjoying our loaf with butter and raw honey.
kellypea says
What a great site you have here. I've not seen it before, and I'm enjoying it with my Saturday cup of coffee. I love soda bread and this looks like a great recipe. The caraway seeds are a pleasant addition. I recently tried a new soda bread recipe and used a skillet to bake it in. It helped with the wet dough, and I enjoyed the resulting shape. I also added raisins, which I'd not tried before. I'm thinking your currants would be excellent.
eliza says
Ah, that would make a difference. I'll be mindful of that with the baking recipes in the future.
Jenny says
Eliza -
I'm at 10,000 ft, and I always wonder how my baking recipes apply to those at lower elevations. Trying to get it figured out!
- J
eliza says
According to the internet 1200-1250 ft. I didn't think that qualified for high altitude shenanigans.
Jenny says
Eliza -
What's the elevation where you live?
- Jenny
eliza says
Didn't work for me either. When I checked it at 25 minute the top was already turning dark brown. I turned off the oven and left it in for another 10 minutes in hopes that the middle might not end up completely uncooked. It came out over cooked on the outside and very undercooked on the inside. I can't imagine cooking it for the full 40-50 min, at least not at the temperatures listed.
LeahMarie says
mine turned out really dense as well. I haven't tasted it yet but I'm worried.
amanda says
I made this soda bread with spelt flour--its so good i can't stop eating it. seriously--for those of you with wheat intolerances, fear not the spelt flour soda bread!
Maddy says
Let it cook for over an hour... The center was doughy. Real heavy and threw it out. This was a costly experiment...Don' think I'll make it as a bread maker. LOL
Jenny says
Jenn -
You're going to *love* this recipe. The caraway really makes it, and while it's not a traditional Irish soda bread in the sense that it includes more than flour, buttermilk, salt and baking soda, it is so good. It'd be a fun way to celebrate your new-found heritage. Much of my heritage is Irish too.
- J
Jenny says
Toola -
Are your magazines free from print ads? Are your newspapers free from advertising? Is your TV free from commercials? Are your highways free from billboards? Is your yahoo.ca email account free from banner ads? Do you work for free?
You're damned right I accept advertising on my site, and will continue to do so while maintaining both the integrity of my site and its message. About one-half the ad space on my site is dedicated to not-for-profits. All the banner ads currently running on the site are for not-for-profits with the exception of my own product. All the companies listed in the resources page are small, family-owned companies that provide real and traditional foods that many of my readers would not otherwise have access to.
Moreover, don't be moronic or melodramatic: not a single recipe on this site is contingent on you purchasing a product flown in from thousands of miles away.
If you don't like it, don't read it.
Blessings -
J
toola says
Salut
I'm appalled at the advertising here. It seems to me you're promoting consumerism, just of different products. As an analogy, I'll mention people who garage sale three days a week in summer and think they aren't shopping.
The nourishment in my kitchen doesn't depend on me shopping at organics/health food stores and buy expensive and thousands of miles flown or driven speciality items.
Are you getting paid in some way, product or money, to run the ads here and promote products?
Will what you send via e-mail be advertising for products, and coupons and for ingredients and products I will be advised to buy in order to re-create the recipes.
I'd like to know the answers before I decide whether or not I let the marketplace into my inbox.
Jenn AKA The Leftover Queen says
Oh wow, Jenny! This looks so good. Thank you for the recipe. I just recently found out that I might have some Irish heritage, and this is going to be a great way to celebrate St. Patrick's day this year!
Jenny says
Jessica -
You're absolutely right: if the grain has already been sprouted you don't *need* to soak it too, and if you're planning to soak the flour, you don't necessarily need to use sprouted flour too. It's my personal preference to use sprouted flour for everything - even sourdough. It's easier for me to have only sprouted flour in the house and I find it easier to digest overall - even with soaking or souring. Find what works for you.
- Jenny
Jenny says
Hey Tiff -
I'm so glad you liked this! I love the addition of caraway in the bread. I think it provides a nice contrast to the sweetness of the currants. We'll have to do dinner some time soon.
- J
Jenny says
Nancy -
You canabsolutely substitute kefir for buttermilk in soda bread. I've done it many times. You can also use sour milk too.
- Jenny
Jessica says
Hi- this looks delicious! But I'm so confused, and this is something I've been wondering for awhile since I have been buying sprouted flour. I thought the soaking process was to be done if the flour is not sprouted- an alternative. Are you saying that for all the recipes in NT and on other blogs that call for soaking, I just use my sprouted flour and still soak? I guess I thought this defeats the purpose, because the phytates are already reduced by the sprouting method...I'm new at this so bare with me, thanks!!
Nancy says
Would kefir be okay to sutstitute for buttermilk?
Nancy says
Would kefir be okay to substitute for the buttermilk?
Tiffany says
Jen made this the other weekend and i got to try some and it was yummy. The caraway seeds really added a nice flavor.
emily says
such a pretty picture, as always.
Heather T says
Great Recipe...
Bon Appetite just ran an article in their last issue on Soda Bread and I was pondering searching for a recipe with soaked grains...
Thanks for reading my mind...
Heather
Ricki says
I love soda bread and bet this one is lovely. I'm pretty sure it would also work with spelt--must give it a try!
Jenny says
Jessica -
I hope you try the brown soda bread, it's really tasty - very flavorful especially with the combination of whiskey-soaked currants and caraway seeds. Caraway is so deliciously fragrant - I love using it!
Blessings -
Jenny
Jenny says
Tina -
If you're using sprouted flour, you do not have to soak the the flour overnight. Sprouted flour is sort of pre-soaked since the grains have been germinated, many of the antinutrients have already been mitigated. I use sprouted flour exclusively in our house - even for sourdoughs. It just makes things easier to have one flour, you know?
- Jenny
Jessica @ How Sweet says
Love the twist on traditional soda bread. Would love to dig into this.
Erin from Long Island says
I have to be a copy cat and say how I love the story within the recipe, or is it the recipe within the story? Your recipe is quite similar to mine (minus the flour soaking) and I look forward to trying yours....like tommorow! I always say mine is not 100% Irish soda bread, but neither am I so it's ok. ; )
Leah says
This looks so nice. I'm going to experiment with smaller amounts so I can come up with a gluten free version.
Tina~ says
Hi!
This sounds incredible- can't wait to try it.
Do you need to soak the flour overnight if you are using a sprouted flour?
Thanks!
Cara @ Health Home and Happiness says
This looks/sounds great! I don't like fruit in my bread, so I'll just leave it out. I love the way you write your recipes- it's like reading a good story for us real food lovers!