Scotch Broth, a humble potage of lamb, split peas, barley, and vegetables, fills my family's bellies in wintertime when the lingering cold and snow seem to draw out our strength and internal warmth. Scotch Broth has long been a favorite of mine - thick with split peas and barley, flecked with long-simmered bits of tender lamb meat and ladled into waiting bowls.
Jump to Recipe
Jillian says
I know this is terrifically old, but I wanted you to know that my teenager considers this their absolute favorite meal, and has requested it as a birthday meal for many years running. I am happy to oblige, as it's delicious, and it also freezes well, so it's a gift that keeps giving!
I wonder, can you clarify "room the lamb"? Is that just a typo for "remove"?
KT says
Recipe sounds amazing and just what I'm looking for. Curious though about a minor discrepancy. Ingredient list calls for 1 lamb shank, and the instructions consistently refer to shanks in the plural.
One or two?
Raelene Hayes says
Glad I found this recipe, thank you!
Liz Hartwell says
I love this recipe! I have a gluten sensitivity which i am not very respectful of, and used barley the few times I have made this. The barley apparently is offensive to my GI system. So this time I am going to use farro perlato in place of the barley. Its not gluten free, but low in gluten and apparently better digested by folks who have gluten sensitivities. I will let you know how it turns out.
Also, I added some extra butter and a little half and half at the end. You can also use cheese rinds in the simmering part to add some extra richness. One time I added some fancy mushrooms which made it very good too. The wonderful thing about this recipie is that you can modify it for your own needs and its awesome no matter what.
Thank you for sharing this recipe, its one of the staples in my house!
Stephanie says
what would be a good substitute for lamb? Would a certain cut of grass fed beef work?
Amanda says
I'm a vegetarian, so I'll be leaving out the lamb, but I can't wait to try this soup! The barley + split peas combination sounds perfect. 🙂